Georgia courts toss suit claiming use of plaintiff's trademark as Google Ads keyword constituted theft of personal property
03 February 2021 (Edited 03 February 2021)

Judges ruled that auctioning off the opportunity to advertise using trademark as keyword does not deprive the mark owner of any property
Subscribe to my blog

Share This Article

A seriously lame lawsuit filed against Google by fruit-basket seller Edible IP dba Edible Arrangements in 2018 alleged that permitting Google Ads advertisers to run ads using 'Edible Arrangements' as a keyword constituted "theft of personal property, conversion, money had and received, and civil RICO" (i.e., a violation of the Georgia Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act of which was enacted for the purpose of seeking to eradicate organized crime).

The thrust of Edible Arrangements' case was that Google committed theft of its trademarked name by allowing its sale as a keyword in Google Ads auctions.

Note that for whatever reason, the Edible Arrangements filing did not address trademark infringement per se.

(As stated in its advertising policies, Google if so requested by a mark owner will restrict the use of a company name or trademark in the text of paid search ads, but not its use as a keyword.)

A Georgia State Court judge ruled:

"Google has not taken Edible IP’s trade name or sold it for profit. Rather, Google has auctioned off the opportunity to advertise on the results page produced when an individual types the keyword phrase “Edible Arrangements” into the Google search bar….it does not “deprive” Edible IP of any property…Creative pleading cannot convert Google’s advertising program into a theft by taking..."

(I like that reference to "creative pleading".)

Edible Arrangements appealed that finding, but on Friday Georgia Senior Appellate Judge Herbert E. Phipps affirmed the lower court's decision.

I believe this suit must have looked like a non-starter from Day 1 to everyone but Edible Arrangements' attorneys. How much money did this waste for everyone concerned over 3 years?

Learn more about how you can use and benefit from Google paid search ads in your business.

If you found this article helpful and would like to see more like it, please share it via the Share This Article link at the top of the page.

And if you have questions or comments, you can easily send them to me with the Quick Reply form, below, or send me an e-mail.

David Boggs    - David
View David Boggs's profile on LinkedIn

Google Certifications - David H Boggs
View my profile on Quora
Subscribe to my blog

Visit Website
4/5 based on 1 vote.
Show Individual Votes
Tags , , , , ,
Related Listings
External Article:

Quick Reply
Subscribe to my blog:
Your Comment:

You may use BB Codes in your message.
Spam Prevention:

Members currently reading this thread:

Previous Article | Next Article